“I remember you,
You had a body,
You had hands and arms and legs and et cetera.
“Call it black star, call it pain star” – repetition of ideas, gives the impression that he really cares about what he’s singing which I think is maybe another reason I identify so much with it. A lot of the ideas he repeats don’t necessarily make sense to anyone else but him.
“The concept of the Pain Star originates from a dream that a friend of Toledo and Wurtz had. A Pain Star only comes once every several thousand years, and when you touch it, you feel unfathomable pain all throughout your body, but only for a split second.”
Without this explanation the pain star means nothing. I think Will writes for himself first, and the audience second.
Common themes are religion (god gets referenced a lot, and bible verses), otherworldly abstract ideas (pain star, not enough to love the unreal, inseperable from the impossible) and humans and physical bodies (you had hands and arms and legs, we wanted to be humans) he speak about humans and their bodies as if he is outside of it, as if he himself if not human.
“The final terror is in your house somewhere” – As referenced later in the song, Will’s lover suffers from mental issues. These lyrics introduce this problem as “The final terror”. The references to mental illness are conveyed by the lines “in your house somewhere” (the house symbolising the lover himself)
When Will says “A pain star has entered your house” the word house could be being used in the same way, to represent the body.
“I am a good person. I am a powerful person. I don’t believe in evil. I think that evil is an idea created by others to avoid dealing with their own nature. I understand my own nature. Good and evil have nothing to do with it. I understand myself. I control myself. I control everything within myself. My domain is my domain. I can lie on my back and affect the lives of those I love without moving a finger. But I would only affect them in good ways. I don’t waste time on evil. I’m a good person…
…A pain star has entered your house, but what are you going to do about it? Are you going to touch it? It only once happens every thousand years, maybe even two thousand years.”
You’re most susceptible to evil when you don’t think you’re capable of it – From and interview with Will. I think a lot of his lyrics is him addressing and referencing a lot of his own harmful ideas/toxic coping mechanisms. I feel like he knows his attitudes are sometimes negative, and I love that he doesn’t shy away from that or make himself look like a good person. There’s a lot of self awareness and honesty.
There were signs on the road that warned me of stop signs
The speed limit kept decreasing by ten
It was almost raining at the train station
We put our hoods on our heads at the train station…
I pretended I was drunk when I came out to my friends
I never came out to my friends
We were all on Skype
And I laughed and I changed the subject
She said, “what’s with this dog motif?”
I said “do you have something against dogs?”
Get more groceries get eaten
By the ones you love
What should I do? (Eat breakfast)
What should I do? (Eat lunch)
What should I do? (Eat dinner)
What should I do? (Go to bed)
Where can I go? (Go to the store)
Where can I go? (Apply for jobs)
Where can I go? (Go to a friend’s)
Where can I go? (Go to bed)
////It should be called anti-depression
As a friend of mine suggested
Because it’s not the sadness that hurts you
It’s the brain’s reaction against it//// – I just really like this lyric, quite comforting, there’s not something wrong with you, the pain comes from your brain’s effort to fight against it. Maybe there’s something comforting about joint pain. Having someone else to wallow with. I also get this feeling with Sober To Death – “You can text me when punching mattresses gets old, what if it’ll always be this way, not comforted by anything I say, we were wrecks before we crashed into eachother.”
///////////
I am almost completely soulless
I am incapable of being human
I am incapable of being inhuman
I am living uncontrollably
It’s not enough to love the unreal
I am inseparable from the impossible
I want gravity to stop for me
My soul yearns for a fugitive from the laws of nature
////////////
“And it was my favorite scene
I couldn’t tell you what it means
But it meant something to me” – I think the idea of understanding that you don’t understand is really important in my work, so naturally when this line was added in the 2018 rerecorded version I absolutely lost my shit because not only does this song put into words everything I’ve ever felt in my life, Will added a line that puts into words everything I love about this album.
He’s not afraid to look small and pathetic and afraid. I think he reflects this in the way he sings as well, the thing that particularly drew me to Car Seat Headrest in the first place was how raw his singing voice is, his voice cracks and warbles and he wails a lot and it makes him look like a blubbering weenie and I LOVE IT. Twin Fantasy is the most unfliltered album I’ve listened to, lyrically, musically, and vocally.
“But I don’t wanna die, I don’t wanna die
I don’t wanna die, I don’t wanna die
I don’t wanna die, I don’t wanna die
I don’t wanna die, I don’t wanna die
And I said hell is the sun
Burning forever at the centre of things
A ball on fire at the centre of things
A ball on fire at the centre of things
A brain on fire at the centre of things
A brain on fire at the centre of things…” – Toledo introduces hellish undertones when he insists “hell is the sun.” From this, “a ball on fire” symbolises the Judeo-Christian idea of hell. In a final metaphor, Toledo compares the sun to the brain, and more deeply, hell to the agony and depravity of existence.
Sober to Death is subtitled “sickening sickening humans” which feels important. I guess in a way this links to the line from Beach Life-In-Death “We wanted to be humans, we said we hated humans”. It gives the impression that there’s a level of disgust towards human nature but also affection towards it, kind of like when you see a really stinky stray cat and are immediately filled with feelings of disgust and affection.